Suspension of H1-B visas may be a blessing in disguise for Indian IT industry



Background

India’s IT industry revenue was around US$ 191 billion in FY20 at 7.7 per cent growth y-o-y. It is estimated to grow to US$ 350 billion by 2025. Moreover, by 2025, revenue from the digital segment is expected to form 38 per cent of the total industry revenue and the digital economy is estimated to reach US$ 1 trillion. For FY 2020, domestic IT industry revenues were US$ 44 billion, export revenues US$ 147 billion and the industry employed 44 million.
Pic: meity.gov.in

Geographical distribution of revenues

Indian IT companies have a significant global presence. About 200 Indian IT firms are present in around 80 countries globally.

Why a blessing in disguise?

Most Indian IT companies derive more than half of their revenues from the Americas. However, the recent decision to suspend the H1-B visas by the Trump administration is a blessing in disguise as the most likely scenario is for businesses to shift to India.

Such an eventuality can confer the following benefits:

Work shifts to India: Despite visa suspension, US firms availing IT support from India would prefer Indians as suitable talent is in short supply locally. Moreover, they would prefer continuity in service delivery. Scouting for new talent or changing vendors may not be preferred as these may turn out to be costly. The pandemic has already renewed the trust for offshoring more work to India.

Higher employment: In the current scenario of COVID, shifting more work to India will increase employment opportunities for fresh graduates who would have been otherwise hit badly. Domestic IT firms and captives of global giants here expect hiring to increase by 15% now as against 8-12% estimated earlier. Besides, new opportunities will open up for those who lost their jobs due to the COVID outbreak.

Margin positive: Shifting work offshore from the US to India is margin positive and a win-win for all. While global companies definitely gain access to a vast talent pool at a reasonable cost, Indian IT firms will be saved from huge salary expenses due to employees being sent for onsite work abroad. Besides, export revenues will also go up as Rupee is expected to weaken going forward.

More global in-house centers (GICs): India has around 1,300 captive centers of global technology companies employing nearly one million. Visa and immigration curbs in the US are expected to result in more GICs coming forward to set up base in India. India offers several advantages such as an English speaking talent, availability of enough graduating pool to pick from, cost efficiencies in infrastructure, etc. Besides, they can make India a global export hub.

Growth headroom offered by the BFSI segment: India’s BFSI segment will be critically dependent on the up-gradation of digital and IT infrastructure for future growth. Since the scale of digital expansion is still low in India, the headroom available to the IT industry would be huge. Domestic IT companies as well as GICs will have enough space to benefit from this opportunity if they focus more on India.

Less movement of senior talent: As existing as well as new GICs ramp up their in-house centers in India, there will be lower movement of the senior leadership team to headquarters. This results not only in cost reduction but also lead to a faster decision-making process. The overall impact will be better profitability for the companies.

Indian IT companies will benefit as they can now increase the share of Indian revenues from below 5%.

An alternate scenario

Indian economy is expected to contract by 5% in 2021. If recovery doesn’t happen as expected in subsequent years, this will adversely impact IT projects and they may relocate.

Also, if global economy grows slower than expected, IT exports too will weaken. This will put a stop to GICs plans to make India an export hub. Higher FII inflows and probable INR appreciation can also be a dampener to exports.

It is important to note that Trump is facing an election and he may announce populist policies to lure global giants towards U.S.

Tax cuts or even a waiver till year-end may be announced. Despite US debt being more than 100% of its GDP, he announced a massive US$ 3 trillion stimulus. Going by this trend, it shouldn’t be surprising if he announces more sops for the IT sector

Japan has announced a grant of US$ 2.2 bn for any company willing to relocate from China. It is possible that Trump comes up with a similar version for IT companies willing to relocate to US.

While India has its own advantages, it faces stiff competition from other emerging locations such as Poland, Romania, Budapest, Costa-Rica, and Brazil as large multi-nationals explore potential geographies to set up their GICs.

Skills which should be in focus


­­­­­­­­­­­­­­DISCUSSION QUESTIONS


1) Despite US contributing more than half of IT cos’ revenues, the decision to suspend visas for tech workers is a boon. Explain


2) As Global In-house Centres set up base in India, which are the key skills likely to be in demand?


3) List some unique advantage that India offers to multi-national companies to set up captive centers.


4) How does the US move to curb visas benefit Indian IT graduates?


5) How do more in-house centers of global firms speed up decision-making?


REFERENCES


  1. Annual reports of respective companies
  2. livemint.com
  3. economictimes.com
  4. IT & ITeS Industry in India, IBEF
Dr. Madhavankutty G
Dr. Madhavankutty G

Prior to joining ET Prime, was Senior Economist with Bank of India. Prior to that was an Economist in Andhra Bank (now Union Bank of India) and also served in ICFAI University as a research fellow.
Also a Member of the IBA Monetary Policy Group, and was a visiting faculty in Economics area at NMIMS University, Navi Mumbai and K.J.Somaiya Institute, Mumbai.
Holds a Masters in Business Economics and is a Certified Associate of Indian Institute of bankers (CAIIB)


Disclaimer

  • All rights are reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or copied in any form by any means without written permission.
  • The views expressed in this publication are purely personal judgments of the authors and do not reflect the views of The Icfai Society
  • The views expressed by the contributors represent their personal views and not necessarily the views of the organizations they work/represent
  • All efforts are made to ensure that the published information is correct. The Icfai Society is not responsible for any errors caused due to oversight or otherwise

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related Post

%d